| Forum Home > Non-Seiko General Discussion Area - Contemporary Chrono's > Close Calls and Double Takes - but not the real deal | ||
|---|---|---|
|
Member Posts: 202 |
Here we are! Konvolut 7 Quartz Uhren für Bastler: Louis Royal, Trend Time, Puma, SM, JM, Aqua Did anyone spot the watch on the left side?
According to seller's description it's a Louis Royal Chronograph Uhrwerk: Akita 4GY1 Seem's it could be a 7A28 inside, but it's hard to tell from that photo....the dial is hardly visible. | |
| ||
|
Site Owner Posts: 14428 |
Well, spotted (again), Arpad ! I can't believe the eBay seller posted individual head shots of all the other watches, but not that one. I tried zooming in on it, in the group shot, but the result wasn't too clever:
Best I can tell, the L.H. sub-dial appears to be marked 20, 40, 60 - as we've normally come to expect from these 7Axx Wannabe clones. | |
| ||
|
Site Owner Posts: 14428 |
Hence my comment in this recent thread in the eBay section about a 7A28 Franken, currently listed on eBay in France: http://www.seiko7a38.com/apps/forums/topics/show/12860018 'Rare' 7A28 Franken re-surfaces on eBay France - Caveat Emptor !
Originally posted (by myself) May 12, 2014 at 5:12 PM But then look closely at those sub-dials - and their markings ! This is a cut-and-shut split dial, using only the original JDM dial's top plate. God knows what movement is actually lurking underneath. But I suspect it very probably originated in one of these 7Axx Wannabe clones discussed, at length, in this other thread: | |
| ||
|
Member Posts: 202 |
I messaged the seller for some pics about the Louis Royal watch above. Here are they:
As we predicted it is not a 7A28 movement. It looks it's got the same calibre as the GUCCI has at the bottom of the first page pointed out by Lawrence. | |
| ||
|
Site Owner Posts: 14428 |
Well done - thanks for following up, Arpad. Speaking of 7A28 wannabe clones spotted in 'Job Lots', here's one currently listed on eBay Italy: http://www.ebay.it/itm/261473484370 Tris cronografi da uomo Sector, Pryngeps, Lancaster
The relevant part of the seller's description: Un cronografo al quarzo Pryngeps tre contatori il quadrante tra il numero 8 e 9 ha lieve segno del tempo, modello Sky pilot , cassa acciaio e ghiera laminata in oro fondello marchiato pryngeps il cronografo è privo di un pulsante in corrispondenza del 2, il cronografo è funzionante come tempo ma non posso dire che la parte cronografica funzioni in quanto manca il pulsante. Translates as: A quartz chronograph with three counters Pryngeps the dial number between 8:09 has slight sign of the time, model Sky pilot, steel case and bezel gold plated case back marked Pryngeps the chronograph is missing a button at the 2, the chronograph is functioning as a time but I can not say that the chronograph functions as a button is missing. So it's effectively the same as the panda-dialed Pryngeps Sky Pilot, which I started off this thread with, but fitted with a different bezel - and missing one of those oblong pushers. Before you ask - No, I'm not going to bother asking the eBay seller for additional photos. | |
| ||
|
Site Owner Posts: 14428 |
It's a pity Lawrence linked photos direct from eBay listings in some of his posts, rather than re-host them in his PhotoBucket .... Because as shown in the quoted post, eBay doesn't retain images for very long - sometimes they disappear after only 90 days. Anyway, I was googling something completely different and just happened to stumble across another Jean d'Eve on Japanese blog: http://www.geocities.jp/rocknrolltwest/watch.html
| |
| ||
|
Site Owner Posts: 14428 |
I'm not sure if he meant this as an April Fool's joke, but this morning I received a 'heads up' PM's from forum member Don .... Check this out: Ebay US--# 131469643331 Got that 7A layout ! Exitedly I copied the item # into eBay's advance search window: http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/131469643331
DANIEL MINK CHRONOGRAPH WRISTWATCH Mens. Swiss made. Very nice, stylish, modern sports look. Excellent working condition. MSRP $995.00 My excitement was short lived. | |
| ||
|
Site Owner Posts: 14428 |
It's been 18 months since anybody posted anything in this thread and well over 3 years since I previously first wrote about these particular 7Axx lookalike clones by Carrera. I'm about to put that to rights, so I trust readers won't mind me quoting the couple of relevant posts from the previous page, 'cos I'm going to do it anyway. | |
| ||
|
Site Owner Posts: 14428 |
That was a great post by erstwhile contributor Lawrence. I'd forgotten to mention that I did have a bid on that one, but it was less than 50 Euros and I didn't win. Knowing what I do now, I wish I'd gone much higher. Lawrence was only partially correct in his observation, however. It isn't actually the same caliber that we'd discussed previously (with a date added at 3 o'clock) - as seen in the ZentRa and Gucci chrono's on page 1 of this thread. Those have 6 jewels, only one stepper motor but two batteries ! In fact, it's something rather more akin to the 7Axx - in that it also has 15 Jewels and 3 stepper motors. Of more anon .... | |
| ||
|
Site Owner Posts: 14428 |
Hindsight is a wonderful thing - or in our colonial cousins' parlance - 20/20 vision. Now, three years later I am really kicking myself for passing on that NOS two-tone Carrera. If only I had taken the gamble. It transpires it didn't contain a Ronda (nor ETA) movement - as far as I can tell, but another make I've never heard of. Something to note from that German eBay seller's description is the Carrera model case-back reference # - 515.12 | |
| ||
|
Site Owner Posts: 14428 |
Strangely, I wasn't actually searching on Carrera at the time (but something vaguely related) when I stumbled across an all-stainless version, listed by a US eBay seller, last week. It came up as one of those eBay 'suggestions'. Remembering this thread and instantly recognizing it, I resolved not to let it slip through my fingers this time, as this seller had not only written a lengthy and very enthusiastic description, but had also included a photo of the movement. http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/172380872009
THIS IS A WORKING, PRE-OWNED VINTAGE CARRERA SWISS QUARTZ 3 REGISTER CHRONOGRAPH WATCH, GUARANTEED AUTHENTIC. PERHAPS THE MOST FINELY BUILT SWISS QUARTZ CHRONOGRAPH I'VE EVER HANDLED. I COULD NOT FIND ANOTHER EXAMPLE - I'M NOT EVEN SURE THIS WATCH WAS EVER (WORN) OR OFFERED FOR SALE- IT COULD BE A PROTOTYPE. CASE, CASE BACK AND BRACELET CLEANED AND UV SANITIZED. MOVEMENT INSPECTED, CLEANED AND TIMED. BRAND NEW PREMIUM BATTERY INSTALLED. LUBRICATED. EXCELLENT WORKING , AND COSMETIC CONDITION - NEAR MINT CONDITION GRADE! ################################################################3 CIRCA LATE 1980S -1990S CARRERA SWISS CHRONOGRAPH ~20 ATM (200 METER) WATER RESISTANT STAINLESS STEEL MENS WATCH. THE WATCH IS POWERED BY ITS ORIGINAL, TOP GRADE MTM SWISS CALIBER 869.10 ~ 15 JEWEL 3 REGISTER (and 3 function pusher) QUARTZ CHRONOGRAPH (1/10 SECONDS, 60 SECONDS AND 60 MINUTES) WITH QUICK SET DATE COMPLICATION . WATCH TIME AND DATE IS SET BY USE OF CROWN/STEM LOCATED AT 8 HOUR POSITION. CHRONOGRAPH START AND STOP FUNCTION PUSHER LOCATED AT 2 HOUR POSITION. CHRONOGRAPH RESET (ALL CHRONOGRAPH REGISTERS HANDS GO TO "0" POSITION) FUNCTION PUSHER LOCATED AT 4 HOUR POSITION. CHRONOGRAPH HANDS ADJUSTMENT FUNCTION PUSHER LOCATED AT 10 HOUR POSITION. THE MOVEMENT WAS CLEANED, TIMED AND LUBRICATED. BRAND NEW SWISS PREMIUM BATTERY INSTALLED. SPOTLESS ORIGINAL 29MM FLAT BLACK -WITH BRIGHT SILVER REGISTERS "REVERSE PANDA" STYLED CHRONOGRAPH DIAL. "CARRERA CHRONOGRAPH 200 METERS " PRINTED UNDER 12 HOUR POSITION. 1/10 SECOND, 60 SECOND AND 60 MINUTE CHRONOGRAPH SUB-DIALS LOCATED AT 3, 6 AND 9 HOUR POSITIONS RESPECTIVELY. APPLIED RAISED WHITE GOLD HASH STYLED HOUR MARKERS. CONTRAST PRINTED BEVELED TACHYMETER REGISTER LOCATED ON DIALS EDGE. POLISHED WHITE GOLD HOUR, MINUTE , AND (TIME) SWEEPING SECONDS HAND. DATE WINDOW LOCATED AT 3 HOUR POSITION ON DIALS EDGE.
NEAR MINT CONDITION 37.5 MM WIDE X 43.5MM LONG, BRUSHED SOLID STAINLESS STEEL 200 METER WATER RESISTANT CASE . CASE IS 12MM THICK (WITH BEZEL AND CASE BACK). LITTLE TO NO EAR ON CASE. NO WEAR ON SLOTTED POLISHED BEZEL. LITTLE TO NO WEAR ON SCREW DOWN DIVER CROWN AND 3 CHRONOGRAPH FUNCTION PUSHERS. SCREW DOWN STAINLESS STEEL CASE BACK -LITTLE TO NO WEAR ON CASE BACK - STILL HAS FACTORY PROTECTIVE CLEAR PLASTIC INTACT. RUBBER O-RING SEAL INSPECTED AND LUBRICATED . CASE BACK THREADS, AND CROWN TUBE THREADS, AND FUNCTION PUSHERS LUBRICATED WITH SILICON GREASE. I NOTICED 1 SMALL SCRATCH AT 10 HOUR POSITION ON MINERAL CRYSTAL. NO CHIPS OR CRACK. ORIGINAL TOP GRADE SOLID LINK STAINLESS STEEL DEPLOYMENT BRACELET ADJUSTS TO ACCEPTS WRISTS UP TO 9" ( OR 220MM). MILLED (NOT LAYERED) SOLID STAINLESS STEEL BRACELET LINKS ARE ALTERNATING POLISHED AND BRUSHED. IT MEASURES 18MM WIDE FOR ENTIRE LENGTH- AVERAGES 3.5MM THICK. LITTLE TO NO WEAR ON SURFACES OF BRACELET - IT COULD PASS FOR NEW. SPOTLESS CLEAN.SIGNED TRI-FOLD DEPLOYMENT CLOSURE WITH SIGNED FOLD OVER SAFETY. COMMENTS: CLASSIC CHRONOGRAPH DIVER - NEW LONG LIFE SWISS BATTERY. SERVICED AND CLEANED - RUNNING STRONG, ALL FUNCTIONS TESTED - KEEPS EXCELLENT TIME, READY TO WEAR! Sorry, but I'm not responsible for additional charges or costs (such as customs, import duties, VAT, or any other taxes) incurred by your local Government. Customs policies vary from country to country, you MUST contact your local Customs Agency with any questions or liabilities. International Bidders I understand the high cost of import fee and will work with you on the value of the item declared. WINNING BIDDERS PLEASE CONTACT ME AFTER PAYMENT WITH REQUESTS. I WILL COMBINE SHIPPING TO SAVE YOU MONEY!! I CAN OFTEN SHIP 3 TO 5 WATCHES FOR THE SAME PRICE AS ONE! IN THE RARE CASE THAT THE WATCH OR WATCHES ARE NOT WORKING PROPERLY when received: Please contact me first, and DO NOT GO TO YOUR LOCAL WATCHMAKER. If you give me a chance - and send me back the watch - I'll fix it, and ship it back to you for free (or I'll FULLY REFUND full cost of watch including SHIPPING AND RETURN SHIPPING). If you decide not to send back the watch and fix it on your own, (even though a Paypal dispute) the fixing costs will eventually be your responsibility not-withstanding all your efforts. I'm always ready to accept returns and fully refund my customers. So please, if trouble occurs, let me know the details first. Ebay Policy recommends this course of action and I enjoy open communication with my customers. Thanks for looking - Brian. Check out my other items! I won the auction, which ended in the early hours of Wednesday morning, for a not unreasonable price of $102.50. http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/172380872009
It turns out that the seller had previously listed it at the beginning of October with a Buy-it-Now price of $500 !! http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/182198249498
Indeed, it appears he'd first listed it (again as a Buy-it-Now for $500) as far back as July: http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/172257807422 | |
| ||
|
Site Owner Posts: 14428 |
Not that it particularly needed it, as the eBay seller's photo was already plenty clear enough .... But here's that shot of the movement rotated through 90°, showing the MTM maker's mark and the caliber # 869.10.
So far, I've had zero success finding out anything about it online. Any google search including the term 'MTM' simply returns dozens of those ridiculous-looking uber-macho pseudo-military MTM Special Ops chrono's. I make NO apology for my contempt of the wannabe morons who wear such pretentious junk. Slightly Just out of curiosity, I ran a worldwide search on 'Carrera 15J Chronograph' on ended eBay listings to see if I'd missed any others. I found one that sold for a mere $29 at the end of September, except it's not quite the same .... http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/201673947141
It has a 15 jewel metal movement (a MTM Cal. 869.60, rather than 869.10) with the same (7Axx) crown and pusher arrangement and a date window @ 3 o'clock, but with a 7Txx sub-dial layout !
| |
| ||
|
Site Owner Posts: 14428 |
Original post content moved by Admin. For further information on the Carrera 15J 7Axx lookalikes, please see separate new topic: Attack of the Carrera 7Axx Clones. | |
| ||
|
Site Owner Posts: 14428 |
Here's a 7A28 clone that really grabbed my attention and made me do a double take. It was listed in the early hours of this morning by a Spanish eBay seller. Yeah - ORIENT and Spain again .... Think back to page 2 of this thread, where Lawrence and I discussed those 'fake' Orient Watch branded 7A28 clones ..... Of course Orient Watch Co. did actually produce pukka re-branded 7A38's and 7A48's (in the form of the J39 and J38). But this is something different again - and it isn't Orient's (missing) re-branded version of the 7A28 .... it's a J85 for starters. http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/322541899084
RELOJ de CUARZO. CALIBRE JAPONÉS CALIBRE ORIENT. REFERENCÍA J85109. CAJA CROMADA MATE. CORREA DE PIEL DE VACUNO. MEDIDAS 37 milimetros Y 10 de GRUESO. NUEVO SIN ESTRENAR PROCEDENTE DE ESTOC DE TIENDA. PEQUEÑAS SEÑALES DE ALMACENAGE. ENVIO POR "MRW"100% ASEGURADO. It was the block capital CHRONOGRAPH dial script that first caught my eye. But almost immediately my attention turned to the minute counting sub-dial. Naturally, like nearly all the 7Axx clones in this thread*, it's graduated to 60 minutes, rather than the 7Axx's 30. At only 50 Euros, I was almost tempted to hit the Buy-it-Now button - just to find out what movement lurked inside .... But as I was already seriously over-spent on watches this week, I decided to hold fire, at least for the time being. * Just scrolling back though past images, the J85109-41's dial is very similar to those of the two ZentRa's on page 1 of this thread. | |
| ||
|
Site Owner Posts: 14428 |
Once again, curiosity got the better of me .... But not quite inquisitive nor intrigued enough to hit the Buy-it-Now button. Instead. I sent a message to the Spanish eBay seller, asking if he could supply a photo of the movement inside the Orient J85. He kindly responded very quickly, by embedding three in his reply to my message and also uploading four to his eBay listing:
No great surprise then, with the Orient J85's dial looking so similar to the ZentRa, that their movements should be almost identical. It's obviously the same Chinese made (ISA copy?) movement, with two batteries. The difference being this one's marked as having only '1 ONE JEWEL', whereas the ZentRa claimed '6 SIX JEWELS' and ORIENT is crudely printed across the battery +ve retaining strap. Kind of disappointing in a way; I'd expected something a little better from Orient. So I'm glad I resisted the temptation. | |
| ||
|
Site Owner Posts: 14428 |
As you can see, from the date of the partial quote, it's been a good few years since I can remember last seeing any of those Kamatz '7A28 Clones' listed on eBay. By an amusing coincidence, a US eBay seller has listed two of them, within the last 48 hours - and they're the same dial colour combinations - a 'Panda' and a 'Reverse Panda'. Though they're clearly not the same watches, These are complete and in rather better condition. Plus they both have the 'Diver's bezel, compared to the Compass points bezel and none (missing), of the French eBay seller's examples. Note that these Kamatz '7A28 Clones' don't have any model number engraved on their case-backs, unlike their 7A38-powered 5xx000 siblings. http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/293414255197
Kamatz Paris Gentleman's Chronometer/Tachometer., full working Triple Chronograph with quartz analog movement. Very limited production of these watches made. Sub dials with 1/5th of a second, 30 minute, and 12 hour, and timed chronograph. It is water resistant to 10 atmospheres (330 feet) and has a directional ratcheted numbered outer bezel. Easy read dial, screw down locking crown with crown guards, and twin sealing gaskets. Screw back cover, solid stainless case, elegant embossed leather band. Band shows some aging and wear at strap. Impact resistant mineral crystal. Professional ratcheting two-tone bezel. Screw down Crown for safety and security. Split second and lap time chronograph for competition timing. Incredibly Water Resistant to 300 feet. Inset Tachometer Ring. Three pushers for Chrono function. Three subsidiary dials. Regular second, minute and hour hands. Day and date indicators. Deluxe, heavy, fine leather band in Brown. A very handsome watch. Made by 'Kamatz of Paris'. Manufacturers List Price $695.00. ------------ CONDITION - PRE-OWNED, NORMAL WEAR AND EVERYDAY USE MARKS. STRAP END IS DISCOLORED, NO PAPERS OR MANUAL. PLEASE SEE ALL OF OUR PHOTOS FOR A BETTER LOOK AT CONDITION AND FOR THE ITEM YOU WILL RECEIVE. ------------ REMEMBER, WE WILL SHIP FAST AND FREE ON THIS ITEM! --- and once you receive that item, if there is any problem, issue or concern - please let us know right away. Your satisfaction is a priority for us. http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/303440328352
Kamatz Paris Gentleman's Chronometer/Tachometer., full working Triple Chronograph with quartz analog movement. Very limited production of these watches made. Sub dials with 1/5th of a second, 30 minute, and 12 hour, and timed chronograph. It is water resistant to 10 atmospheres (330 feet) and has a directional ratcheted numbered outer bezel. Easy read dial, screw down locking crown with crown guards, and twin sealing gaskets. Screw back cover, solid stainless case, elegant embossed leather band. Band apears brand new, and is the proper Kamatz signed version for the original release.
Impact resistant mineral crystal. Professional ratcheting two-tone bezel. Screw down Crown for safety and security. Split second and lap time chronograph for competition timing. Incredibly Water Resistant to 300 feet. Inset Tachometer Ring. Three pushers for Chrono function. Three subsidiary dials. Regular second, minute and hour hands. Day and date indicators. Deluxe, heavy, fine leather band in Brown. A very handsome watch. Made by 'Kamatz of Paris'. Manufacturers List Price $695.00. ------------ CONDITION - PRE-OWNED, NORMAL WEAR AND EVERYDAY USE MARKS. STRAP APPEARS BRAND NEW AND UNWORN, NO PAPERS BOX OR MANUAL. PLEASE SEE ALL OF OUR PHOTOS FOR A BETTER LOOK AT CONDITION AND FOR THE ITEM YOU WILL RECEIVE. ------------ REMEMBER, WE WILL SHIP FAST AND FREE ON THIS ITEM! --- and once you receive that item, if there is any problem, issue or concern - please let us know right away. Your satisfaction is a priority for us. The two listing descriptions are virtually identical, save for the condition of the strap. (Both are fitted with their original Kamatz straps). Both include the same erroneous statement: Sub dials with 1/5th of a second, 30 minute, and 12 hour .... Whereas they clearly have a 60 minute counting sub-dial; a fractions of seconds sub-dial with increments marked in 1/20th's and a constant seconds sub-dial. So they've either copied that mis-information from somewhere, or just haven't looked at the dials very closely. The French eBay seller, typically, never did respond. I'm wondering if it might be worth asking the current US eBay seller for a photo of the movement. Purely out of curiosity, you understand. I suspect it's likely to be something similar to those dual battery composite movements in the Zentra and Orient, higher up the page. | |
| ||
|
Site Owner Posts: 14428 |
Well I guess we'll never know. http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/293414255197
http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/303440328352
| |
| ||
|
Site Owner Posts: 14428 |
This afternoon, I was casually browsing the Swedish auction site Tradera.com and spotted this VISA branded chronograph, fitted with a leather strap, which I assume is a replacement for the original bracelet. It was a 7-day auction, which ends in an hour or so. The bezel / case design bears a resemblance to a couple of 7Axx's.
The One jewel, twin battery composite movememt looks like the same one we've seen a few times before - most recently in that Orient, higher up the page. No I'm not interested - not even for £20 quid. Belated Edit: I thought that 7Axx-esque case design looked familiar. It's the same as the ZentRa which I posted on the first page of this thread.
| |
| ||
|
Site Owner Posts: 14428 |
Apart from my recently renewed dalliance with the MTM powered Carrera 515.11, I've not stumbled across (or, if I'm honest even actively searched for) any more of these 7Axx clones. Hence the reason the thread hasn't been updated in 5 months. However, it seems others have done so. Since reluctantly signing up to Instagram, I've had late-night online conversations with a few forum members, who've sadly drifted away. One such is alan776600, a.k.a. Alan Symes, who nowadays runs the Seiko Passion FaceBook group. I asked Alan to write this post up himself, but he replied saying he'd prefer if I did it, as not only is he too busy with FaceBook and Instagram, he's currently also away on holiday. Just over a week ago, Alan emailed me this photo of a ZEON branded 7Axx clone.
.... Asking: I know it’s not a 7A movement but do you know what brand is in it? I replied: Dunno, Alan. Never really tied it down to a particular manufacturer, though some people have pointed at ETA. The giveaway is the 60 minute counter (not 30). There are loads of photos of similar 7Axx clones using that movement (including shots of it) in this thread. Correcting myself, I followed that with: I just re-read a bit of it again myself. I referred to it as a Chinese-made ISA (not ETA) clone. Alan opined that elements of it made him think it was possibly connected to Seiko. I later replied: It's also quite reminiscent of the Citizen 35xx Chrono' Diver.
As he was being a bit coy at the time, I guessed that Alan had either just bought it on eBay, or was considering doing so. I did a quick search on 'Zeon Chronograph', but didn't find it, so I asked him for a link, which he kindly provided. He had indeed just bought it. http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/184168125178
| |
| ||
|
Site Owner Posts: 14428 |
Here's the eBay seller's other 11 photos and listing description:
Zeon Mens Watch. Has a Chronograph function but it doesn't seem to work. The new owner will have to get it fixed if they want a chronograph, otherwise works fine. Blemishes, light scratches on the case, bezel and bracelet. Wear to the Rotating bezel. Faint, light scratches on the glass, does not effect the telling of the time or look of the Wrist size approx. 205mm **This watch has been fitted with a Brand New Swiss Renarta or Seiko Battery** PLEASE SEE ALL PHOTOS FOR MORE DETAILS!! This watch doesn't come with its original packaging or paperwork. There are no extra links, so please ensure wrist size before bidding, Thanks. Used Watches/Ex-Display Watches With all used & ex-display watches we can't guarantee the life of the battery or the water resistance. **PLEASE CHECK OUT OUR OTHER ITEMS** Please read the full item description, notes and table above before bidding. Despite being away on holiday in Scotland, Alan was evidently keen to get his hands on it, because he asked the seller to post it to the address of a relative or neighbour, where he was staying. Here's a wrist shot he sent me via Instagram. Doesn't look too bad at arm's length.
Alan was also keen to find out what movement it had inside. Here's a shot of it.
Also taken while Alan was away on holiday. That's dedication / passion for you. No great surprise, just as I'd suspected, it's another of those unidentified composite 2-battery movements. Fingers crossed for Alan that replacing the other battery will solve the non-functional chronograph issue. | |
| ||